| Aether | 12x | No | Fish becomes a translucent light blue, with a white hole at the centre of it and blue sparkling particles circling it. Only obtainable via natural fishing at a 0.004% chance. |
| Fury | 11.7x | No | Fish is a bright orange, surrounded by orange particles Only obtainable with Castbound on an extra fish |
| Hades' Curse | 11.1x | No | Fish is in transparent green color, surrounded by green and black particles. Only obtainable with the Hades' Soul-Scythe at 100% chance during passive. |
| Tryhard | 10x | No | Fish becomes a translucent red, with bright sparkling particles around it. Only obtainable with the Tryhard Rod at a 100% chance. |
| Plagued | 10x | No | Fish becomes an obsidian-like black with some texture. Only obtainable with the Plaguereaver at a 15% chance. |
| Ascended | 9.9x | No | Fish is in faintly translucent and white color. Only obtainable with Masterline Rod at a 25% chance. |
| Gravitas | 9.81x | No | Fish is in black and purple color, with orange fogs around it and purple lightning/runic symbols around it. Only obtainable with the Olympian Godbreaker at a 30% chance. |
| Requies | 9.8x | No | Fish is in dark green color with green particles surrounding it. Only obtainable alongside a Husk fish, which is only obtainable with the Requiem at a 20% chance. |
| Fabulous | 9.6x | No | A vibrant glow radiates around the fish, which is covered in smoke and emits sparkles around it. Can be obtained with the Fabulous Rod (26% chance) |
| Poseidon's Blessing | 9.55x | No | Fish is dark-blue in color, surrounded by floating water particles, and a light-blue light beam at the centre. Only obtainable via fishing after charging bar is full in Poseidon's Storm of Floods . |
| Permafrost | 9.5x | No | Fish becomes a bright white color with snowflake particles falling off of it. Can be obtained with the North Pole at a 25% chance. |
| Withered | 9.5x | No | The fish is dark-brown in color. Only obtainable with the Withered Spear at a 25% chance. |
| Royal | 9.4x | No | The fish is golden-yellow and red in color with smooth texture. Only obtainable with the Royal Spear at a 35% chance. |
| Darkness | 9.4x | No | Only obtainable with the Sword Of Darkness (100% chance during passive) |
| Zeus's Storm | 9.3x | No | The fish is yellow in color, and lightning particles surrounding it. Only obtainable with the Zeus's Thundermaul at a 10% chance. |
| Verdant | 9.2x | No | The fish is pale-green in color, with green particles surrounding it. Only obtainable with the Verdant Oath at 100% chance for a perfect catch. |
| Frostbitten | 9x | No | Fish becomes a dark blue with snowy particles around it. Only obtainable with the Maelstrom Rod (30% chance) |
| Umbra | 9x | No | Fish appears with a mixture of bright orange, black, and blue colors, with a large black hole around it. Can only be obtained when using the Fang of the Eclipse during an Eclipse for 15 minutes at a 10% chance. |
| Mossy | 8.7x | No | Fish becomes dark green, with a grassy/mossy texture, and sparkling green particles around it. Only obtainable with the Elder Mossripper at a 5% chance, or 100% chance every 2 minutes. |
| Puritas | 8.7x | No | Fish becomes a mixture of two shades of light blue, with a ring present around the fish, and a butterflies present around it. Only obtainable with the Onirifalx at a 3% chance. |
| Igneous | 8.65x | No | The fish becomes orange in color, with some transparent parts and fire particles surrounding it. Only obtainable with the Igneous Rupturer at a 30% chance. |
| Breezed | 8.6x | No | Fish changes between yellow and white colors, with a rocky texture. Only obtainable with the Wind Elemental at a 25% chance. |
| Distraught | 8.5x | No | Fish becomes black and white emitting a distorted effect around it. Only obtainable with the Dreambreaker at a 25% chance (35% during night) |
| Blessed | 8.5x | No | Fish becomes bright white and yellow neon, with a winged particle in the center of it. Only obtainable with the Seraphic Rod with a 30% chance. |
| Serene | 8.5x | No | Fish becomes a darker shade of blue, with trailing particle effects. Only obtainable with the Polaris Serenade with a 20% chance or with the Duskwire with a 2% chance or a 4% chance after a perfect catch. |
| Sovereign | 8.5x | No | The fish is grey-purple in color, with rock texture. Obtainable with the Propensity Spirit enchantment at a 15% chance. Obtainable when fishing in sovereign Surge/Storm/Reckon Beam at a 5% chance. |
| Floral | 8.4x | No | The fish is green foliage texture with light pink, blue, green, red, yellow parts. Obtainable with the Gardenkeeper Rod at a 25% chance. Obtainable while fishing in Living Garden . |
| Obsidian | 8.3x | No | Only obtainable using the Obsidian-Bone bait at a 10% chance. |
| Mastered | 8x | No | Fish becomes translucent while changing between blue and red colors, along with gleaming particles around it. Only obtainable with the Ruinous Oath after doing a perfect catch at a 100% chance. |
| Gleebous | 8x | No | Fish becomes neon green with green particles. Can be obtained with the Blade Of Glorp at a 23% chance Can also be obtained with a 5% chance at the Roslit Bay UFO crash. |
| Glacial | 8x | No | Fish becomes a mixture of white and light blue, with a snowy texture and snowflake particle effects. Can be obtained with the Frostbane Rod at a 1% during any season than Winter, and at a 10% during Winter. Can also be obtained through certain Admin Events . |
| Glowy | 8x | No | Fish becomes grayish-white along with being very bright, similar to the Sparkling attribute. Obtainable with Glowworm bait at a 100% chance, or with Noctone at a 40% chance. |
| Nocturnal | 8x | No | Fish becomes completely dark, with obsidian-like textures. Only obtainable with the Wingripper during night at a 7% chance. |
| Atomic | 8x | No | Fish becomes bright yellow, with multiple neon particle effects around it. Only obtainable in the radius of a Atomic Nuke at a 100% chance for 45 minutes. |
| Chaotic | 8x | No | Fish becomes partially translucent, with black and white parts, and emits particle effects. Can be obtained with the Chaotic enchant. Can also be obtained with the Duskwire at a 30% chance without a perfect catch, and 98% chance after a perfect catch. Can also be obtained with the Axe of Rhoads at a 5% chance. |
| Tentacle Surge | 7.8x | No | Fish becomes grainy texture and will fade into a midnight-to-medium blue and then fades back to its normal color. Only obtainable with the Kraken Rod (5% chance). |
| Jackpot | 7.77x | No | Fish becomes glow bright yellow and green. Only obtainable with the Random Rod (50% chance). |
| Magical | 7.2x | No | Fish becomes purple, with a sandy texture. Only obtainable with the Merlin's Staff at a 25% chance with it's passive. |
| Infernal | 7x | No | Fish turns bright orange with a rocky texture, emitting blazing fire particles. Only obtainable with the Cinderstring at a 5% chance during it's first stage, and at a 15% chance during it's last stage. |
| Flora | 7x | No | Fish becomes purple, with a sandy texture and butterflies circling around it. Only obtainable with the Chrysalis at an 8% chance, or 100% chance when it's passive is activated. |
| Diurnal | 7x | No | Fish appears completely dark, with obsidian like textures. Only obtainable with the Wingripper during day at a 27% chance. |
| Sacratus | 7x | No | Fish becomes a mixture of two shades of light blue, with a star in it. Only obtainable with the Onirifalx at a 7% chance. |
| Shrouded | 7x | Yes | Fish becomes translucent forest-green, with many particles around it. Can be obtained with the Elder Mossripper at a 25% chance. Can be also appraised at a 0.03% chance. |
| Tidal | 7x | No | Fish becomes light blue with water particles. Only obtainable with the Rod Of The Forgotten Fang at a 25% chance. |
| Prismatic | 6.5x | Yes | Obtained from Lullaby at a 24% chance. |
| Evil | 6.5x | No | Fish becomes red, with red lightning particles and dark evil face particles surrounding it. Can only be obtained with the Evil Pitchfork with a 20% chance. |
| Luminescent | 6.5x | No | Fish becomes translucent with a sandy texture. Only obtainable with the Luminescent Oath and the Ruinous Oath at a 100% chance if the fish if perfectly caught. |
| Aurora | 6.5x | No | Fish becomes pastel neon pink with a red, blue, and green glow. Can be obtained with the Aurora Rod at a 15% chance (30% during an Aurora Borealis . Can also be obtained with the at a 15% chance (30% during an Aurora Borealis . |
| Oscar | 6.4x | No | Fish becomes a mixture of red and yellow accents. Only obtainable with Great Rod Of Oscar at a 5% chance. |
| Sunken | 6.3x | No | Fish becomes dark green and emits green smoke along with runic symbols. Only obtainable with the Sunken Rod (8% chance), Treasure Chests with a 3.83% chance for Sunken fish from Forsaken Shores , and Dead Man's Rod (10% chance). |
| Toxic | 6x | No | Fish becomes purple, with a magma-like texture and bubbles emitting from it. Only obtainable with the Toxic Spire Rod at a 15% chance. |
| Nuclear | 6x | No | Fish becomes a radioactive-green color resembling uranium, along with a very bright glow. Only obtainable around waters where a Nuke or Cursed Nuke has exploded at a 100% chance. |
| Snowy | 6x | No | Fish becomes a light blue with snowflakes floating around it Only obtainable with the Fallen Snowblade at a 25% chance (45% during winter and 5% during summer). |
| Chilled | 6x | No | Takes on a white-cyan appearance, emits "Steam" effects. Only obtainable with Frostbane Rod with a 10% chance (30% during winter). Can also be obtained through various Admin Events . |
| Rainbow | 6x | No | Obtained from Lullaby at a 18% chance. Originally obtainable on the Lobster King during a rainbow event, with a 30% chance. |
| Nova | 6x | No | Fish becomes a mixture of white and purple colors. Can be obtained with the Rod Of The Cosmos or the Cerulean Fang Rod at a 15% chance. Can be obtained during the Starfall Server Event with a 5% chance for all players. Can be obtained from Starlight Worms at a 100% chance. |
| Heavenly | 6x | No | Fish becomes a pastel neon yellow with a crucifix symbol. The symbol always faces towards the camera. Only obtainable with the Heaven's Rod (35% chance). |
| Subspace | 6x | No | Fish becomes pink-purple, with dark-pink sparkles. Only obtainable with the Quantum enchantment (25% chance). |
| Anomalous | 5.55x | No | Fish gains red glitchy like particles around it. Only obtainable using the Anomalous enchantment. (20% Chance) |
| King's Blessing | 5.5x | No | Fish gains a crown on top of its head. When catching this mutation with Poseidon Rod , the fish also becomes 75%-150% larger. Only obtainable with the Poseidon Rod (10% chance). |
| Mythical | 5.5x | Yes | Certain parts of the fish glow similar to Sparkling. Increased chances with the Mythical Rod (30% chance). |
| Abyssal | 5.5x | Yes | Fish becomes neon blue, with particles sometimes emitting from it. Increased chances with the Abyssal enchantment (10% chance). Can be obtained with the Abyssal Specter Rod (25% chance) and Rod Of The Depths (30% chance) Has a chance to be appraised by appraiser . |
| Prismize | 5.5x | No | Fish gains a glass-like texture and magenta, black and purple colors. The colors change every time the fish is equipped. Only obtainable with the Ethereal Prism Rod (50% chance). |
| Spirit | 5.2x | Yes | Fish becomes translucent and purple. Can be obtained with the Spiritbinder and Tranquility Rod at a 15% chance. Can also be appraised at a 0.05% chance. |
| Siren's Spite | 5x | No | Fish turns dark red, with a red crown appearing above it. Only obtainable with the Evil Pitchfork at a 25% chance. When catching a fish with this mutation, it will override the current hooked mutation, and apply a 100-200% weight buff. |
| Rainbow Cluster | 5x | No | Similar to Mythical , the fish glows rainbow colours. Only obtainable during rainbow (5%), the Rainbow Cluster Rod (20%, 35% during Rainbow). |
| Levitas | 5x | No | Fish becomes white. Can only be obtained with the Onirifalx at a 50% chance. |
| Cursed Touch | 5x | No | Fish becomes neon green. Only obtainable with the Great Dreamer Rod (20% chance). |
| Nico's Nyantics | 5x | No | Fish becomes various shades of pink and light blue emitting particles of pink confetti, stars, a pink paw, and swirling effects. Only obtainable with the Nico's Yarncaster with a 25% chance |
| Gemstone | 5x | No | Fish becomes a mixture of multiple colors, with a glassy texture. Can only be obtained with the Treasure Rod at a 20% chance. |
| Sanguine | 5x | No | Fish becomes blood red. Can be obtainable with the Blood Reckoning enchant. Can also be obtained with the Sanguine Spire at a 30% chance. |
| Carrot | 5x | No | Fish becomes orange and green. Can be obtained with the Carrot Rod at a 15% chance. Can also be obtained by fishing in a Carrot Pool spawned by Carrot Rod at 15% chance for all players. |
| Ashen Fortune | 5x | No | Fish becomes like lava. Only obtainable with the Volcanic Rod (20% chance) or the Magma Rod (5% chance). |
| Emberflame | 5x | No | Only obtainable with the Blazebringer rod (5% chance at stage 3). |
| Colossal Ink | 5x | No | fish becomes a light blue. Only obtainable with the Colossal Ink Bait (100% chance). |
| Galactic | 5x | No | Fish becomes completely black with a large golden aura around it Only obtainable with the Astrolure Bait (100% chance). |
| Greedy | 5x | Yes | Fish becomes dark golden and glows yellow, with yellow rays flying off it. Increased chances with the Rod of The Eternal King (60% chance) and Scurvy rod (13% chance). |
| Lobster | 5x | No | Fish becomes a dark shade of red. Only obtainable with the Lobster Rod (30% chance). |
| Nullified | 5x | No | fish turns a rainbow neow color while a rainbow glitchy aura emminates around it. Only obtainable with the Nullbit Bait (100% chance). |
| Blackwater | 4.5x | No | Fish is in blue and black color Only obtainable via fishing with Blackwater Leech . |
| Phantom | 4.5x | No | Fish becomes multiple shades of grey and black while also retaining a black aura around it. Only obtainable with Eidolon Rod (35% chance) |
| Wrath | 4.5x | No | Fish is surrounded in a light blue-ish fog or hue with tiny water droplets misting around. Only obtainable in Poseidon Trial Pool waters while Poseidon's Wrath Totem is active (2% chance). Also obtained with Rod Of The Zenith at 70% chance. |
| Lost | 4.5x | No | Only obtainable with the Lost Rod with a 36% chance after a Perfect Catch. Fish becomes bright white and green neon. |
| Seasonal (Spring) | 4.5x | No | TBA. Only obtainable with the Seasons Rod during spring (50% chance). |
| Harmonized | 4.2x | Yes | Fish Gains music note and feather particles Can only be obtained with Pinon's Aria with a 42% chance |
| Stardust | 4x | No | Fish becomes a darker shade of blue, with purple particles around it. Can only be obtained with the Astralhook Rod after a perfect cast, followed by a perfect catch is performed with a 10% chance, and assuming the fish granted by the passive is caught. |
| Bloom | 4x | No | Only obtainable with the Free Spirit Rod (20% chance), and Chrysalis (90% chance). |
| Blue Moon | 4x | No | Visually causes the fish to become transparent, with yellow, purple and green color. It is obtainable with any fishing rod when fishing during a Blue Moon , with a 20% chance. |
| Crimson | 4x | Yes | Fish is almost translucent with a light or darkish red hue. Can be obtained with the Scarlet Spincaster Rod at a 30% chance. Can be appraised at a 0.11% chance. |
| Boreal | 4x | No | TBA. Only obtainable with the Boreal Rod (40% chance). |
| Fungal | 4x | No | TBA. Only obtainable with the Fungal Rod (30% chance). |
| Revitalized | 4x | No | Fish becomes brighter in color. Obtainable by bringing a fish with the Amber mutation to the Chiseler in Ancient Isle for C$100 , with the other mutation being Purified . |
| Seasonal (Autumn) | 4x | No | the fish becomes brown and black similar to rust. Only obtainable with the Seasons Rod during Autumn (50% chance). |
| Atlantean | 4x | No | Fish becomes dark turquoise. Only obtainable with the Trident Rod (30% chance). |
| Celestial | 4x | No | Fish becomes light gold and emits yellow sparkles. Only obtainable with the Celestial Rod (100% chance during Celestial Bonus which lasts 15 minutes). |
| Moon-Kissed | 4x | No | Fish becomes a bright/baby blue with shining particles. Only obtained with a rod with the Blue Moon Blessing obtainable for 24 hours after catching a Moon Idol Sea 1 or Moon Idol Sea 2 (5% chance). |
| Lucid | 3.5x | No | Fish becomes purple with mystical particle effects. Only obtainable with the Lucid Rod at a 20% chance (30% during Clear Weather ) |
| Aureolin | 3.5x | No | Only obtainable with the Auric Rod (20% chance). |
| Electric Shock | 3.5x | No | Fish becomes black and emits dark violet electric sparks. Only obtainable with the Zeus Rod at a 90% chance in the pool. |
| Vined | 3.5x | Yes | Fished by the Vineweaver Rod with a 30% chance, can also be fished at Lost Jungle Can also be appraised. |
| Crystalized | 3.5x | No | Fish becomes glowy, red and orange parts. Only obtainable with the Crystalized Rod (20% chance). |
| Fossilized | 3.3x | Yes | Fish becomes a pastel neon purple and emits particles resembling ancient inscriptions. Increased chances with the Voyager Rod (35% chance). |
| Astral | 3x | No | Fish becomes neon purple. Only obtainable by fishing in an Astral Pool spawned by the Astralhook Rod (80% chance for all players). |
| Quiet | 3x | No | Fish becomes darkish-blue. Only obtainable with the passive of Polaris Serenade at a 100% chance. |
| Aurulent | 3x | No | Only obtainable with the Auric Rod (20% chance). |
| Brother | 3x | No | TBA Only obtainable with the Brothers Rod at a 20% chance. |
| Mother Nature | 3x | No | Fish appears with a brown wooden texture, and leafy patterns. Obtainable with Verdant Shear Rod at a 33.3% chance when a tree spawns. |
| Brown Wood | 3x | No | Fish appears brown with a wooden texture. Obtainable with Verdant Shear Rod at a 33.3% chance when a tree spawns. |
| Green Leaf | 3x | No | Fish appears with leafy patterns on it. Obtainable with Verdant Shear Rod at a 33.3% chance when a tree spawns. |
| Cracked | 3x | No | Fish becomes a mixture of dark blue and neon orange. Only obtainable with the Blazebringer Rod (10% chance when stage 2). |
| Ember | 3x | No | Fish becomes a mixture between red, orange, and red-orange. Only obtainable with the Blazebringer Rod (15% chance at stage 2, and 95% at stage 3. |
| Blighted | 3x | Yes | Fish becomes black and purple. Only obtainable during a Blizzard event at a 25% chance, or with the summit rod at a 10% chance or the ice warpers rod at a 25% chance. |
| Solarblaze | 3x | No | Fish becomes a glowing orange and emits flame-like particles. Increased chances during an Eclipse , or with Fang of the Eclipse at a 10% chance normally or a 90% chance during an Eclipse . |
| Scorched | 3x | Yes | Fish becomes entirely black and emits blazing-orange smoke and flames. Increased chances with the Phoenix Rod (40% chance). |
| Aureate | 2.5x | No | Only obtainable with the Auric Rod (20% chance). |
| Lunar | 2.5x | Yes | Fish becomes neon yellow and purple. During a Moonlight Mirage, if a fish with this mutation is caught naturally, the next fishโs weight and value will be increased by 5%, stackable until 25%. Increased chances with the Astral Rod and the Event Horizon Rod (5% chance). |
| Seasonal ( Winter ) | 2.5x | No | Fish becomes powder-blue in color. Only obtainable with the Seasons Rod during Winter. |
| Sludged | 2.5x | No | Fish is in translucent purple color. Only obtainable when fishing with Smudge during Foggy at a 10% chance. |
| Skrunkly | 2.5x | No | Fish becomes grey with grey stars and paw prints emminating around the fish. Obtainable through using Nico's Yarncaster .(30% chance) |
| Midas | 2.5x | Yes | Fish becomes entirely gold. Increased chances with the Midas Rod (100% chance). |
| Purified | 2.5x | No | Fish returns to its normal appearance. Only obtainable by bringing a fish with the Amber mutation to the Chiseler in Ancient Isle for C$100 , or a 30% chance with the Insight enchantment. |
| Sleet | 2.4x | No | Fish becomes blueish-gray. Only obtainable during an Avalanche event . (10% Chance) or with the Avalanche rod with a 25% chance. |
| Oak | 2.3x | No | Fish becomes wooden. Only obtainable with the Eardrum after every 2 catches. |
| Electric | 2.1x | Yes | Fish emits (typically) yellow electricity sparks. Increased chances when fishing in the Grand Reef (15% chance) or with the Storming mutation during rain (50% chance). |
| Forgotten | | No | Only obtainable with Thalassar's Ruin on an extra fish. |
| Aurelian | 2x | No | Only obtainable with the Auric Rod (20% chance). |
| Lumpy | 2x | No | Fish becomes a bright purple with yellow stars and a mix of yellow and purple circles rapidly appearing around it. Obtainable via Nates Blade . |
| Rockstar | 2x | No | Fish becomes completely black with black lines, red skulls and red and black stars all around it. Obtainable via Nates Blade . |
| Bubblegum | 2x | No | Fish becomes mostly pink with various shades of dark pink. Obtainable via Nates Blade . |
| Honked | 2x | No | Fish gets a red clown hat on its head. Obtainable via Silly Fun Happy Rod . |
| Lightning | 2x | No | Fish gets a blue, black lightning aura around it. Can be in the Zeus Rod Room while the Zeus Storm Totem is active. Can be obtainable with Test Rod at a 5% chance. |
| Studded | 1.8x | No | Fish becomes blocky with studs on all sides. Only obtainable with the Brick Rod (100% chance). |
| Silver | 1.8x | Yes | Fish becomes silver-like, with smooth textures. |
| Glossy | 1.6x | Yes | Fish becomes light blue with a sheen during daytime. Fish appears to be regular but darker during night. |
| Aurous | 1.5x | No | Only obtainable with the Auric Rod (20% chance). |
| Hexed | 1.5x | Yes | Fish becomes dark red and emits red electricity-spark-like particles. Increased chances with the No-Life Rod (50% chance). |
| Mosaic | 1.5x | Yes | Fish becomes pastel-colored, resembling a vibrant mosaic painting. |
| Darkened | 1.5x | Yes | Fish becomes entirely black. Increased chances with Noir enchantment (50% chance). |
| Frozen | 1.5x | Yes | Fish becomes encased in an ice block, similar to Amber . Increase chances with Arctic Rod (100% chance). |
| Cement | 1.5x | No | Fish becomes grey and adds the Roblox Concrete texture. Only obtained with the Cinder Block Rod . |
| Negative | 1.3x | Yes | The fish's color is inverted. |
| Translucent | 1.3x | Yes | Fish becomes partially transparent. Increased chances with the Ghastly enchantment (100% chance). |
| Amber | 1.2x | Yes | Fish becomes encased in an orange block, somewhat similar to the Frozen mutation. Bringing a fish with the Amber mutation to the Chiseler in Ancient Isle for C$100 grants either the Purified or the Revitalized mutation. |
| Albino | 1.2x | Yes | Fish becomes entirely white. Increased chances with the Noir enchantment (50% chance). Can be sold to the Ashe NPC for 1.3x. |
| Seasonal ( Summer ) | 1x | No | Fish becomes gold-yellow in color. Not inclusive of the 25% size boost during Summer. Only obtainable with the Seasons Rod during Summer. |
| Neon | 1x | No | Fish becomes a neon colour. Only obtained with the Hourglass Bait at a 100% chance. |
| Upside-Down | 1x | No | Fish turns upside down. Only obtained with the Upside Down Rod . |
| Poisoned | 0.9x | Yes | Fish becomes purple. Can only be appraised at a 0.11% chance. |
| Charred | 0.5x | No | Fish becomes completely black. Only obtained with the Zeus Rod at a 10% chance in the special pool. |
| Dirty | 0.3x | No | fish becomes various shades of brown. Only obtainable while using the Earthworm Bait at a 100% chance. |
| Exploded | 0.1x | No | When a fish with this mutation is hooked, a explosion effect appears on it. This does not change the fish's appearance afterwards. Only obtained with The Boom Ball at a 50% chance. |